Just in time for George Vescey's
sympathetic profile of him, I turn my sights to the oft-maligned Luis Castillo. Vescey hit all the requisite notes, talking up Castillo's manliness in facing the media after The Drop and how he actually had a
damn fine competent year at the plate. Why oh why then, do we meanies in Queens keep calling for his head? Many reasons, George, and most of them have very little to with The Drop.
Part of it, I think, has to do with the ridiculous merry-go-round that has been second base in the Omar Minaya era. Every Met fan knows that since the club formed we've employed literally one million third basemen and that with David Wright manning said corner bag we could all rest easy. Except that in the Minaya era, the following ridiculous people have played second base for the Metropolitans: Miguel Cairo, Chris Woodward, Jose Offerman, Kaz Matsui, Anderson Hernandez, Jose Valentin, Ruben Gotay, Damion Easley, Luis Castillo,
Exxon Wilson Valdez and Alex Cora. Oh, and Marlon frakking Anderson played for four innings in 2008. Eleven second basemen in five seasons doesn't breed much confidence in the position.
Why did this happen? Well, Omar got lucky and struck oil with Valentin in 2006 and thought he could repeat his performance in 2007. This made sense because gambling on a 37-year-old who strikes out a ton and never hits for average is the number one rule for success in "How To Build A Better Baseball Team". It's on the front cover actually, in a red starburst with white lettering. In call caps. But duh, Valentin was old and hurt and hey does anyone remember how he struck out with one out and the bases loaded in the sixth inning of Game 7 against the Cardinals? That all he had to do was put the ball in play? How he struck out against Jeff fucking Suppan? That the odds of the Cardinals winning the game when he came to the plate was a paltry 29 percent? That's OK if you don't, go on blaming Carlos Beltran for striking out against a guy who had nastier stuff than Suppan finds on the bottom of his shoe, I'll just be here bitterly remembering how it had come right after The Catch and how the Mets had a ton of momentum before The 'Stache did us in for good. But now I'm off the rails completely and I'd like to get to bed sometime tonight/this morning.
ANYWAY, as the Mets struggled to find an answer at second, Omar finally brought in Luis Castillo, about two years past his expiration date. Still, he was alright and it's not like he did anything to directly aid in the collapse and a month into his Met career he had a walkoff RBI against Trevor Hoffman. When the season was over and the free agent landscape wasn't great at second base, no one would have been apoplectic if Luis came back. Until of course Omar Minaya had some kind of stroke and gave a 32-year-old with creaky knees a four year contract. What?
2008 was of course horrible and forgettable and appeared to be a sign of things to come for the next three years. Castillo showed up next spring talking about how in shape he was, how his knees had been replaced with computer parts and how he would show us all. And show us all he did, at least until that fateful night in Yankee Stadium where I almost collapsed on the bar floor, barely mustered up the focus to continue along on my date and actually called my dad to see if he had survived it. From them on, it wouldn't have mattered if Luis Castillo batted .400 and offered to rend his garments after every game. A team that was a poorly assembled, injured circus show found its defining moment, and all before the All-Star break.
The other reason everyone hates Luis Castillo is that his name isn't Orlando Hudson. Hudson has basically thrown himself at the Mets for two off-seasons now and the Mets have coughed, looked embarrassed and stuttered something about how "This never usually happens" before Orlando found homes with better teams. Here's something you may not know about Orlando Hudson: Luis Castillo had one more extra base hit for all of 2009 than Hudson had home runs and triples, 16 to 15. Another thing you may not have known was that Orlando Hudson's defense was worth 3.5 runs to the Dodgers. Luis Castillo's defense was worth -5.9 runs to the Mets. Sadly, that was an almost 8 run improvement for Castillo from 2008. This is why I stand by my contention that continuing to play Luis Castillo and Daniel Murphy on the right side of the infield will be a disaster. Really going out on a limb there, I know.
So yes, Luis Castillo, if he repeats his 2009 offensive year on a team that will theoretically run actual major league players out there, will be less of an albatross than he appears to be. But he'll still be merely average compared to his peers and that's discounting his deteriorating defense. So to answer Vescey's question of why Met fans pick on Luis Castillo, I'll simply answer that he just isn't very good at baseball.